The Health, Safety and Wellbeing Partnership Group (HSWPG) recognises that bullying can have a detrimental effect on an individual’s overall health and wellbeing. The group aims to support NHS organisations to build a culture where employees can work in an environment that is free from fear of intimidating behaviour.
What is workplace bullying?
Workplace bullying can take many forms. ACAS defines bullying as; 'offensive, intimidating, malicious or insulting behaviour, an abuse or misuse of power through means that undermine, humiliate, denigrate or injure the recipient (ACAS 2014).'
The bullying perpetrator can be a work colleague or peer; a manager or a subordinate. Bullying can lead to increases in individual stress levels. The Health and Safety Executive’s Management Standards on stress states that relationships can be a potential risk, increasing strain on an individual if not managed properly.
Poor organisational cultures may lead to environments where bullying can thrive, especially where there is a focus on targets over patient outcomes and where staff concerns are not listened to. As we have seen with Mid Staffordshire and the subsequent Francis report, bullying cultures can impact negatively on patient outcomes, as well as having devastating effects on individuals concerned.
The extent of the problem
Bullying has become an extensive problem within healthcare. Twenty per cent of all NHS staff report they have been bullied within the workplace and 29.9 per cent of all NHS staff indicated experience of psychological distress due to bullying behaviours. For further information on the impacts of bullying and harassment and what can be done by an organisation and an individual to tackle it, take a look at the bullying and harassment in the NHS infographic.
What does the research say?
There is a detailed evidence base page available which includes information and links to research, resources, guidance and tools.
This research has been used to show impacts of bullying and harassment on an individual and an organisation.
The Health, Safety and Wellbeing Partnership Group’s (HSWPG) core principles:
A partnership approach
HSWPG recognises the importance of managers and trade union representatives working in partnership on this agenda. This includes the development of a proactive approach, joint training, jointly agreed policies and early identification of problems. This approach can promote trust, a shared understanding and create a positive culture. The HSWPG partnership working page provides further details and guidance for creating partnerships.
An organisational approach
Every organisation should have a strong message on bullying - that is not tolerated in any shape or form and is regarded as gross misconduct within the conduct policy. Creating a working environment where all staff are treated with respect and everyone feels valued is key to the prevention of bullying behaviours.
It is important to have a policy that promotes dignity at work along with a learning and development programme to promote respectful relationships. Proactive initiatives such as values based recruitment, effective and timely appraisals, fair and transparent application of absence management or flexible working policies and raising concerns policies can also contribute to prevention. The prevention and management of work related stress is key to developing dignified working environments.
Tools available to support the promotion of respectful relationships:
A focus on prevention and the identification of early warning signs
The results of staff surveys show that workplace stress audits and data such as grievances, sickness absence, exit interviews, organisations, can identify problem areas or hot-spots within organisations. The HSWPG stress guidance supports the need for prevention through early identification and effective stress management.
A proactive response to complaints
Bullying is defined largely by its impact rather than its intent. All reports of bullying must be taken seriously and be responded to promptly. Policies and procedures that facilitate informal resolution, joint working between managers and trade union representatives, mediation and early resolution of conflicts should be implemented, further details for this are found in the ACAS guidance.
Support for individuals
Being bullied or accused of bullying can have a devastating impact on individuals concerned, including their work colleagues/teams. The provision of counselling/employee assistance programmes along with dignity advocates or cultural ambassadors should be encouraged. Trade unions can provide support for individuals and there are organisations that provide contactable help and advice regarding bullying and harassment in the workplace such as UNISON, Royal College of Nursing, Unite, Royal College of Midwives and Society of Radiographers.